Table of content

Journal on Ethnopolitics and Minority Issues in Europe

ISSN/EISSN: 16175247
Subject: Political Science --- History
Publisher: European Centre for Minority Issues
Country: Germany
Language: English
Start year 2000
Publication fee: No --- Further Information

Journal homepage at publisher site


Table of content: 2007 volume:6 issue:1

Article
Fit for Purpose or Faulty Design? Analysis of the Jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights and the European Court of Justice on the Legal Protection of Minorities

Authors: Anneleen Van Bossuyt
Pages: 1-20
Loading...
Loading...
Abstract

This paper examines whether the European Court of Justice (ECJ), even in the absence of explicit competencies, could play a role in the creation of a European Union policy promoting the protection of minorities and thus preventing their social exclusion. Comparison is made with the jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) because of the cross-fertilisation between the two Courts. The author argues that there is a conspicuous absence in ECJ jurisprudence on the rights of minorities to their culture and identity, whereas the jurisprudence of the ECtHR in this regard is progressive. In contrast, the ECJ takes the fore when it comes to the protection of the linguistic rights of minorities. In conclusion, the author argues that the ECJ is not fit for purpose, but that to speak of a faulty design is taking a step too far.


Article
The Educational Rights of the Muslim Minority under Greek Law

Authors: Iris Kalliopi Boussiakou
Pages: 1-25
Loading...
Loading...
Abstract

The right of the Muslim minority of Western Thrace to receive education in the mother tongue is provided by the Treaty of Lausanne and the educational bilateral agreements-the Educational Agreement (1951) and the Cultural Protocol (1968)-signed between Greece and Turkey. Due to certain particularities in the educational system, however, minority students do not have adequate opportunities to gain knowledge of the Greek or Turkish language. The major problems the Muslim minority faces in education include: a mixed system of administration, outdated textbooks, poorly-educated teaching staff and the absence of an efficient school curriculum. This article will provide a critical analysis of the existing legislation on education provided to Muslim students in the minority schools of Western Thrace. Secondly, an examination will be made of the level and status of minority education in light of current international human rights treaties documents for the protection of minorities. The existing inadequacies of the educational system will be addressed to provide a series of effective solutions and recommendations in favour of the advancement and improvement of education in minority schools. The article will therefore examine the principle that education needs to be made available and accessible at all levels to the member of a minority group and, most importantly, it needs to adapt to the socio-linguistic and cultural needs of minority students.


Article
Real and 'Virtual' Elements of Power Sharing in the Post-Soviet Space: the Case of the Gagauzian Autonomy

Authors: Oleh Protsyk --- Valentina Rigamonti
Pages: 1-22
Loading...
Loading...
Abstract

Various efforts to assess the effects of autonomy arrangements on the prospects of achieving stability and democracy in ethnically heterogeneouos societies receive a lot of attention both in academic and policy-making communities. This paper argues that the analysis of the actual implementation practices of autonomy settlement agreements should be an integral part of such efforts. Taking implementation practices seriously means going beyond the analysis of grand formal provisions listed in the autonomy's constitutional law or statute, which is usually adopted at the end of the conflict settlement process. The actual implementation process can produce an autonomy regime whose functioning is far from the model autonomy arrangement envisioned in the autonomy's founding documents. Successes and failures in securing stability and democracy then can be better accounted for by studying the effects of these implementation practices rather than by attributing democracy and stability outcomes to formal autonomy provisions.


Article
Ethnic Minority Protection and Anti-discrimination in Central Europe Before and After EU Accession: the Case of Poland

Authors: Peter Vermeersch
Pages: 1-21
Loading...
Loading...
Abstract

This article explores key policy developments regarding ethnic minority protection and anti-discrimination in contemporary Poland. More specifically, it examines the relationship between domestic policy formation and the European context. Before 2004, the European Union applied membership conditionality in order to attempt to stimulate candidate member states in post-communist Central Europe to adopt special minority protection measures. As a result, most of these countries turned to the official recognition of the ethnic specificity of minority groups and the acceptance of group-related cultural entitlements, not only as norms in their own right but also as the basis for a policy of stimulating ethnocultural diversity in the new member states have been less focused on group-related rights but have emphasized the themes of social inclusion, anti-discrimination and equal opportunities. I explore how, in this new European context, Polish policies on ethnic minority protection have developed. Through a comparison of dominant Polish perceptions of minority protection issues with dominant discourses about the preservation of ethnic diversity promoted by EU institutions, this article shows the linkages between recent developments in Polish minority policy-making and the current European initiatives in this field. It also shows important points of disjuncture between the way in which European institutions have framed issues of ethnocultural diversity and the way in which Polish policy-makers have worked out minority protection.


Article
Introduction: Europe and the Integration of Integration / Contribution to Special Focus Equal Opportunities for National Minorities: Theory and Practice

Authors: Gabriel von Toggenburg
Pages: 1-11
Loading...
Loading...
Abstract

This year, in 2007, the process of European integration had its big birthday party. 50 years have passed since six states began, at the end of March 1957 to integrate their economies. However, 2007 stands also for another, newer dimension of the European integration process: this year was designated by the European Parliament and the council of the EU as being the 'European Year of Equal Opportunities for All'.


Article
A Dual Challenge for the Year of Equal Opportunities for All: Roms in the Western Balkans / Contribution to Special Focus Equal Opportunities for National Minorities: Theory and Practice

Authors: Eben Friedman
Pages: 1-23
Loading...
Loading...
Abstract

The primary aim of this article is to place the current situation of Roms in the Western Balkans in the broader historical context of Roms' experiences since their arrival in the region. A subsidiary aim is to examine some of the ways in which the work of the European Centre for Minority Issues (ECMI) has taken steps to address this situation. beginning with a discussion of Roms' experiences in the Western Balkans from their arrival in the region through the post-communist period. Also offered is a brief examination of some of the difficulties encountered in measuring the size of Romani populations in the region. Presenting in more detail the situation of Roms in Macedonia, Montenegro, and Serbia, the article moves next to an examination of ECMI's novel approach to assessing Roms' needs and to the action-oriented follow-on initiatives designed on the basis of the needs assessments. The conclusion of the article is that lasting change in Roms' status is likely to depend in large part on the integration of the countries of the Western Balkans into the European Union.


Article
The Aspect of Culture in the Social Inclusion of Ethnic Minorities: Assessing Language Education Policies under the EU's Open Method of Coordination / Contribution to Special Focus Equal Opportunities for National Minorities: Theory and Practice

Authors: Ulrike Schmidt
Pages: 1-28
Loading...
Loading...
Abstract

The aim of this article is to highlight a change in the European Union's 'Lisbon Strategy' since its launch seven years ago, in terms of putting more emphasis on culture as an important aspect of social inclusion. The article focuses on a research project coordinated in 2006 by the European Centre for Minority Issues (ECMI), which reviewed and assessed cultural policies aimed at the social inclusion of ethnic minorities introduced in the National Action Plans (NAPs) on Social Inclusion of five new member states of the European Union: the Czech Republic, Estonia, Latvia, the Slovak Republic and Slovenia. Sweden was additionally included in the study with the initial idea of serving as a benchmark in terms of best practices for promoting the inclusion into mainstream society of 'persons born outside Sweden' in its educational and cultural policies. The article will focus on language education policies that have been introduced in the six NAPs.


Article
The Economic Status of National Minorities in Europe: a Four-Case Study / Contribution to Special Focus Equal Opportunities for National Minorities: Theory and Practice

Authors: Jonathan Wheatley
Pages: 1-35
Loading...
Loading...
Abstract

The aim of this study is to investigate the causes and effects of economic exclusion of historical national and ethnic minorities and to identify the policies, both at the national and supranational levels, that are most effective in combating this problem. The study analyzes economic participation in four regions of Europe in which historical minorities are concentrated: the Autonomous Province of South Tyrol/Bolzano (where German-speakers form a majority), Northern Ireland (where Catholics form a large majority), Estonia (where Russians and other Russian-speakers form a majority in the northeastern county of Ida-Viru) and Transylvania in Romania (where Hungarians form a majority in two counties). The main focus is on compactly settled minorities, rather than widely dispersed minorities such as Roma. The paper (Section II) shows how a variety of factors, including constitutional arrangements and other fundamental laws, policies from different fields of policy making, general economic processes, such as privatization or integration into the global marketplace, as well as the strategies adopted by the minorities themselves, affect the relative economic position of members of minorities in the four regions under analysis. This allows us to derive examples of best practice in terms of policy initiatives that can best combat the problem of economic exclusion. The paper concludes by summarizing the policies that are most effective in promoting economic inclusion in our case studies and the ways that these may be employed at a wider EU level.


Article
Equal Opportunities Provisions for Communities in the Comprehensive Proposal for the Kosovo Status Settlement / Contribution to Special Focus Equal Opportunities for National Minorities: Theory and Practice

Authors: Adrian Zeqiri
Pages: 1-19
Loading...
Loading...
Abstract

In light of 2007 being named the 'European Year of Equal Opportunities for All' and the aspiration that Kosovo may eventually integrate into the EU, this article shows how the current proposal for the new state of Kosovo represents, on the one hand, a legal framework that establishes equal opportunities for all in Kosovo, but, on the other hand, risks segregating opportunities further and harming minority communities. Although this study is tentative and speculative in nature, it is vital to initiate debate at this crucial time on the question of equal opportunities in a territory/state that has been so deeply marred by ethnic conflict.

Table of content: 2007 volume:6 issue:1